Independent Living vs. Home Care

Aug 19, 2025 | Assisted Living, Featured

A Better Way to Live Well

When it comes to making decisions about how and where to live as we age, the options can feel overwhelming. Should you or your loved one stay at home with a little extra help, or is it time to move into an independent living community?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but understanding the key differences can help you make a choice that brings comfort, happiness, and the best quality of life.

Independent Living vs. Home Care: What’s the Difference?

Independent living communities are like a dream come true for seniors who value their freedom but don’t want to deal with the hassle of home upkeep.

Think of it like moving into a neighborhood specifically designed for you, one where you can enjoy your privacy and easy access to a vibrant social life, tailored amenities, and optional services like meal plans and housekeeping. It’s all about living life on your terms—with no yard work, leaky roofs, or endless utility bills to worry about.

With home care, on the other hand, you can stay in your own home while getting some professional help when you need it. Whether it’s assistance with daily tasks like dressing and cooking or medical care for chronic health conditions, a caregiver can step in to lend a hand.

Convenience Matters

One of the first things to ask yourself when making this choice is, “how much do I want to manage?”

With home care, it’s on you (or your family) to coordinate everything. Scheduling caregivers, grocery shopping, paying various providers, and handling home repairs can quickly become exhausting, especially for seniors with more significant needs. On top of that, the costs can add up; the national median for 44 hours of in-home care a week is $4,500 a month.

Meanwhile, independent living offers simplicity. Need help with meals or transportation? It’s handled. Want to host family for dinner but don’t feel like cooking? The community dining room has you covered. Even better, you still maintain your independence, but without the stress of managing a house or a lineup of caregiving schedules.

Social Connections

Picture this. You’re at home, and it’s been a few days (or weeks) since you’ve had meaningful interaction with anybody outside of your caregiver or immediate family. Research suggests that social isolation can increase the risk of a premature death by as much as 39%, comparable to the risks of smoking or obesity.

Independent living communities, however, make staying social effortless. With everything from group yoga classes to movie nights and shared meals, you’re part of a thriving community.

Safety First

If safety is a top concern (and it should be!), Independent living communities often offer peace of mind that staying at home can’t match. These communities are designed for seniors, which means fewer hazards like steep stairs or slippery area rugs. Many also come with 24/7 on-site staff, giving you or your loved one an added layer of security.

Home care can help make your current space safer, but retrofitting a home with accessibility upgrades (think wheelchair ramps, grab bars, or wide hallways) can be costly and time-consuming.

d

Categories

Awards

Stay Connected

Newsletter

|

Testimonials

I have visited Brentwood many times. Every time that I am there I am amazed ...
Read More
Steve
I have visited Brentwood many times. Every time that I am there I am amazed at the level of care that I see the residents receive from all the staff. I see the staff talking to the residents and calling them by name and taking the time to chat with them. This might seem like a minor thing but I can tell you, it doesn't happen at a lot of other places. They always have activities planed and there is always a happy group of people participating. Great job Jennifer Kedik and the entire staff.
Steve
Steve
I went in with a family member for a tour, to look for an apartment ...
Read More
Julianna
I went in with a family member for a tour, to look for an apartment for another family member. I could not believe how nice and kind the staff were to eachother, and kind when overheard talking to the residents. The rooms were clean , and the building was well kept, We will definitely be back to Brentwood at Niles!
Julianna
Julianna
I just left from visiting my Mother who is a resident in Brentwood's Memory Care @...
Read More
Tammy
I just left from visiting my Mother who is a resident in Brentwood's Memory Care @Niles . I have to say ,I was happy overall before, but since Brentwood has been under new owners, I can tell that it's even better. My siblings and I agree . Everything is clean, the staff are very helpful and so sweet to my Mom and just feels more organized and the staff look happy. I have been a nurse for 32 years so my expectations are high and I feel that my Mom is receiving the best care she deserves. I know no place is perfect but feel reassured and confident @this point .
Tammy
Tammy
We are so impressed with the fabulous care my dad is getting at Brentwood in ...
Read More
Nancy
We are so impressed with the fabulous care my dad is getting at Brentwood in Niles. The staff are all saints! They are so helpful and sweet! My dad moved in last weekend, Sept. 3, and is very happy and comfortable in his new facility. We could not have asked for a better place. I'm 2 1/2 hours away and my brothers are both 1 1/2 hour away. We feel so much at ease knowing that he is in excellent care. Keep up the fantastic work staff! Give each other a HUGE pat on the back and say "a job well done!"
Nancy
Nancy
My husband and I toured this very nice facility yesterday with Jennifer Kedik, who couldn't ...
Read More
Kimberly
My husband and I toured this very nice facility yesterday with Jennifer Kedik, who couldn't have been more accommodating and helpful. We are looking for a place for my mom. If it comes to the point where her live-in caregiver can no longer stay with her, I would love to have Mom go to Brentwood. It's clean and light, the food looked delicious and all of the staff was friendly. Residents seemed happy and well cared for. We were impressed!
Kimberly
Kimberly
Brentwood is FAMILY!!! From the staff, to the residents to the family members. I cannot ...
Read More
Debbie
Brentwood is FAMILY!!! From the staff, to the residents to the family members. I cannot express the appreciation of this WONDERFUL organization in helping our Seniors remain safe and happy. Thank you Brentwood!
Debbie
Debbie

Recent Posts

a group of seniors holding hands
Aug 04 2025

Supporting the Supporters

Caring for a loved one with memory loss can be draining – here’s compassionate advice to...
A young woman taking a selfie with her grandpa
Jul 07 2025

What is Respite Care and How Can It Help Your Family?

Discover how respite care offers relief for family caregivers while ensuring your loved one...
A senior woman using her walker outdoors, with a senior man by her side providing support.
Jun 27 2025

Fall Risk Reduction in Senior Care

Discover how SafelyYou uses AI video technology to reduce falls, prevent ER visits, and enhance...
Senior woman smiling with a glass of water and two supplements
Jun 04 2025

Boost Your Health

Discover how to choose the right vitamins and supplements to support your health and nutritional...
senior woman with cleaning supplies cleaning a window
May 19 2025

Fresh Start

Refresh your space with our top easy, safe spring cleaning tips for seniors that boost wellness...
senior mother and her daughter hug at the park
May 05 2025

Understanding Dementia

Discover the early signs of dementia with this helpful guide, which helps you recognize symptoms...
diverse group of elderly people embracing
Apr 14 2025

Come Together for Support and Community

Join our support group at Brentwood at Niles for open conversation, shared understanding, and a...
Elderly smiling woman enjoys a peaceful moment outdoors sitting against a tree listening music
Apr 02 2025

Harmonizing Health

Whether it’s tapping your foot to a favorite old tune or joining in a group sing-along, music is a...
Mar 19 2025

Priority Life Care: A Proud Member of Hilarity for Charity

We are honored to be part of Hilarity for Charity (HFC), a nonprofit committed to raising...
Happy senior people after yoga class having lunch outside
Mar 03 2025

Prioritizing Self-Care: Simple Routines for Seniors to Boost Wellness

At any age, self-care is key to living a happy and healthy life, but it becomes especially...

GET THE BROCHURE

Please provide your email to download your brochure.*We will not sell your information to any third party; we will use the email you provided only to reach out to better understand your senior living needs.